RangeRegistry
Menu

Holsters for the 1911 4 to 4.25 in (Commander size)

As of Nov 13, 2026, 5:17 AM CT, 9 holsters whose store listing names the 1911 4 to 4.25 in (Commander size) are listed here from 1 brands. By the carry style named in their titles: 2 inside the waistband (IWB), 1 paddle; 6 titles name no style. A title can name more than one style.

9 holsters whose store listing names the 1911 4 to 4.25 in (Commander size).

A holster is listed here only when its title names this gun, so read the title for the size, barrel length or variant before you buy. Rows are sorted by lowest store price. Holsters that name no gun in our table, such as universal fits, are not listed on a gun page.

Prices updated

We earn a commission on some links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Details.

RangeRegistry earns a commission when you buy through some links, and some placements are paid and labeled Sponsored. Neither affects our sorting, rankings, or data. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Disclosure. How we get prices.

Every 1911 4 to 4.25 in (Commander size) holster, cheapest first

Buy
Galco Tuck-N-Go 2.0 Strongside/Crossdraw IWB Holster, Colt 1911 4.25in, Ambidextrous, Premium Center Cut Steerhide, Black, TUC266B$51.99Buy at OpticsPlanet
Galco Professional Law Enforcement Paddle Leather Holster, Kimber 1911 4in/Colt 1911 4.25in/Springfield Armory 1911 4in/Smith & Wesson SW1911 Sub-Compact 4.25in, Right Hand, Plain, Tan, PLE266$107.99Buy at OpticsPlanet
Galco Combat Master Leather Belt Holster, Kimber 1911 4in/Colt 1911 4.25in/Springfield Armory 1911 4in/Smith & Wesson SW1911 Sub-Compact 4.25in, Right Hand, Tan, CM266$108.79Buy at OpticsPlanet
1 more store
Galco Combat Master Leather Belt Holster, Kimber 1911 4in/Colt 1911 4.25in/Springfield Armory 1911 4in/Smith & Wesson SW1911 Sub-Compact 4.25in, Right Hand, Black, CM266B$111.79Buy at OpticsPlanet
1 more store
Galco Concealable Leather Holster for Kimber 1911 4 inch with Rail, Black, Right Hand CON666B$124.99Buy at OpticsPlanet
Galco Avenger Belt Leather Holster, Kimber 1911 4in/Colt 1911 4.25in/Springfield Armory 1911 4in/Smith & Wesson SW1911 Sub-Compact 4.25in, Right Hand, Plain, Tan, AV266$129.99Buy at OpticsPlanet
Galco Fletch High Ride Leather Belt Holster, Kimber 1911 4in/Colt 1911 4.25in/Springfield Armory 1911 4in/Kimber KDS9c, Right Hand, Plain, Tan, FL266R$136.79Buy at OpticsPlanet
1 more store
Galco Fletch High Ride Belt Holster, Single Stack Magazine Pistols/Para USA 1911 4.25in, Right Hand, Black, FL266RB$143.49Buy at OpticsPlanet
Galco Royal Guard 2.0 Leather IWB Holster, Colt 1911 4.25in, Right Hand, Black, RG266B$158.89Buy at OpticsPlanet

Prices exclude shipping and tax.

Specs on this list are read from the store listing titles, not the maker's spec sheet. "Not listed" means the title does not say.

Same maker

More 1911 (any maker) guns.

1911 4 to 4.25 in (Commander size) holster questions

How many 1911 4 to 4.25 in (Commander size) holsters are listed?

9 holsters from 1 brands, as of Nov 13, 2026, 5:17 AM CT, each with its store's current price.

How many are IWB and how many are OWB?

2 inside the waistband (IWB), 1 paddle, and 6 whose titles name no carry style. These are counts of the words in store titles, so a title that says "OWB Belt/Paddle" counts under both.

How is a holster matched to the 1911 4 to 4.25 in (Commander size)?

Only by its store title naming the 1911 4 to 4.25 in (Commander size). Nothing is inferred from a sibling model, a frame size or a maker's compatibility list, so read the title for the size, barrel length, light or optic before you buy.

Which brands list the most 1911 4 to 4.25 in (Commander size) holsters?

Galco (9), by the number of listings on this page.

Find a holster for your gun

A holster is matched to a gun only when its store listing names that gun. Holsters that name no gun we list are universal or unlisted fit.

See every holster

By RangeRegistry Data Desk · How we source specs and prices · Report a data error